Skip to content

Heritage Ottawa wants 'all-party committee' to oversee 24 Sussex

In a letter sent to the Prime Minister, Heritage Ottawa is asking for the federal government appoint a committee to make recommendations on how to move forward with the rehabilitation of 24 Sussex Drive.
Prospect of fixing up or tearing down 24 Sussex captivates renovation expert
OTTAWA — Be it renovated or razed, the resurrection of 24 Sussex Drive should be documented as a showcase of Canadian history and innovation, says an expert in public portrayals of what — and what not — to do with older home projects.

Heritage Ottawa is calling on the Prime Minister to appoint an all-party committee to look into how to upgrade and evolve the historic 24 Sussex Drive.

"What we're saying is we want something done," said David Flemming, Co-chair of the heritage advisory committee. "The more you neglect the building, the more critical it becomes."

The National Capital Commission said in a report last year, chronic underfunding has left half of the six official residences and many of the associated out-buildings in poor or critical condition.

It's being suggested that Canada would need to spend $83-million over the next 10 years to get the Prime Ministers residence into decent shape.

In addition, the NCC said an annual budget of $24.6-million is needed for ongoing maintenance to prevent significant deterioration.

Heritage Ottawa said in its letter, an upgrade can result in entertainment events and even some public access.

"It could be opened during Doors Open Ottawa every June," said Flemming.

Flemming added, if the federal government decided to create a committee, that it should be chaired by some who is respected across the country, suggesting Former Governor General David Johnston as Chair.

Here is the full letter from Heritage Ottawa:

Dear Prime Minister Trudeau,

Heritage Ottawa respectfully recommends that the Government of Canada appoint a committee headed by a widely respected, non-partisan Chair to make recommendations concerning 24 Sussex and concerning Prime Ministerial accommodation.

Heritage Ottawa is the foremost non-profit group in Ottawa dedicated to the appreciation and conservation of Ottawa’s built heritage and special places. We are writing to you to suggest a go-forward for 24 Sussex Drive, to address the question of conservation of this historic property, and perhaps also provide a path forward for prime-ministerial accommodations.

As you are very aware, this is not just any home. It is a nationally significant place that belongs to all Canadians. It is part of a suite of buildings designed in the Gothic Revival Style erected at the time of Confederation. 24 Sussex (built 1867-68 by Joseph Merrill Currier, lumber baron and member of Parliament), along with Earnscliffe (home to Canada’s first Prime Minister, Sir John A. Macdonald), and the Parliament Buildings themselves are all part of an elegant landscape of structures, located on one of the most dramatic – and iconic – landscapes in Canada that speak to the founding moments of our nation. It has been the setting for many important political events. For these reasons, 24 Sussex is a Classified Federal Heritage Building.

It is tragic that the building has been allowed to degrade.

Heritage Ottawa advocates conservation of this building for the reasons given above. Good heritage conservation allows for buildings to be upgraded and to evolve. In the case of 24 Sussex, it is the exterior walls and landscape which have been identified as historically significant. That given, there is great scope for imaginative and creative rehabilitation and new design. An upgraded building, suitable for a family and small entertainment events, and perhaps even some public access, and yes, which is also ‘green’, is very much possible. The greenest building is the one that is already there. Please do not condemn this fine building to landfill.

We hear the voices of those who feel that a building with such limited public access should not be the recipient of funding. It Is true that 24 Sussex does not have the public profile of the White House or 10 Downing Street (the latter is also not open to the public). But lack of public access can be addressed. Perhaps for one year after rehabilitation the reception spaces of the house could be open to the public. And even once occupied, perhaps it could be open once a year during Doors Open Ottawa, as are many ambassadorial residences in the city. How about an online virtual tour, which would reach all Canadians?

It is lamentable that federally-recognized places have no legislative protection in Canada; we are the only G7 country to lack such protection.

But there is a solution to this: strike an all-party committee, chaired by a respected, non-partisan individual – former Governor General David Johnston comes to mind – to make recommendations concerning 24 Sussex and concerning prime ministerial accommodation which the heads of all political parties might be prepared to live with, and live in.


Jeff Slack

About the Author: Jeff Slack

Read more
Rogers Media
2001 Thurston Drive Ottawa, ON, K1G 6C9 © 2006-2019 Rogers Media. All rights reserved.